September 2010
The $44,000 question: industry insider responses (Alex Niswander)
This is in reference to Melissa Heyboer’s article, “The $44,000 question,” which appeared in Issue 13, 2010. The following are Alex Niswander’s responses in their entirety.
Question 1: How will this affect the chiropractic office? i.e., do you think this program is beneficial
A: After we put aside the pipe dream of being handed a check for $44,000 the impact of global (or at least national Electronic Health Records) will be tremendously positive. The core benefit is speed of accessing patient charts. Currently with a paper model it could take months to get a full patient chart from past offices and there is no way to know what is missing from their history. The program is beneficial because it brings to light the issue that record keeping in general has been sub-standard a long time - consider almost all other industries have been electronic for years. Overall healthcare technology has advanced light years and many doctors are still writing patient charts with pen and paper.
Another thing to consider with general impact is that if your practice finds it difficult or impossibly to afford a software for EMR, it may be time to evaluate your entire practice's ability to succeed.
Question 2: What do chiropractor’s need to take advantage of this incentive? How much will it cost, as far as time and money, to implement?
A: My greatest point on this one is that if someone is only looking for EMR to aquire the incentive, they should save their time and money and stay with paper notes. There is more to this than just buying a software and receiving a large check. There is software, hardware, office changes, design changes, implementation, learning curve, frustration and time, time time. If a doctor is doing this to become more efficient and have better documentation, then this will be highly successful. If they are doing this to cash in on a reimbursement, it is a very painful process and honestly is probably not worth the effort this will take.
They need to:
1. Implement a software that is willing to become certified.
2. Review & meet guidelines for meeting the 'meaningful use' process. I would encourage them to look to their state association for how to do this for office procedure changes needed (similar to Hipaa 10 years ago- some changes may be needed). If their state association shy's away from this responsibility, they need to push them to step up and become the expert on this.
3. Ensure they meet some sort of medicare amounts in order to qualify. Recently someone said to me: "My medicare volume is not enough and I wish they could use my insurance volume for this
Question 3: Will all chiropractic offices qualify? Can cash-based practices benefit?
A: No. It is very clear if you do not have some sort of Medicare volume you will not qualify. I think initial experts estimate you need about 30% medicare volume for a typical practice. Now how to define typical practice is outside of my scope, but I have heard $30,000 per year minimum in order to qualify for reimbursements.
Question 4: When can chiropractors expect to receive payments?
A: Since the 7/13/2010 announcement stated they were just beginning to accept application from certification companies (meaning those who will certify software vendors), this tells me that having certified/endorsed software is still well over a year away. I would estimate payments not starting into 2012 or later.
Question 5: What questions should chiropractors ask their providers (insurance and software) to ensure they are being compliant?
A: Simply ask if they plan to become certified when it is available. Most current companies will likely do this to ensure they stay in business.
Question 6: What new products or services do you think will come out of this incentive?
A: There will likely be chart access from any patient anywhere at a price to doctors. The deep pocketed GE has a recent ad in which a medical record is being downloaded on a i-phone as a patient is being air-lifted following an accident. This is far-fetched, but the general direction things are moving towards and probably the most likely new service would be a monthly subscription to Microsoft's HealthVault of records or similar company as that was my example.
Comments